Historical Romance

Historical Romance Novels With Alpha Heroes and Innocent or Plain Jane Heroines

What readers mean by alpha heroes and innocent or Plain Jane heroines in historical romance, with books to try, content notes and related tropes.

On this page
  1. What the pairing means
  2. Why it works in historical settings
  3. Books to try
  4. Content notes
  5. Related tropes

What the pairing means

This trope combines two familiar figures. The alpha hero is commanding, protective and used to getting his way, often a duke, laird, warrior or wealthy self-made man. The innocent heroine is inexperienced, sheltered or unassuming. A Plain Jane heroine is one who believes, or is told, that she is plain and overlooked, and who is then valued for who she is. The two ideas often overlap, though they are not the same thing.

Why it works in historical settings

Historical societies handed men legal and social power that modern readers don’t expect. That makes a domineering hero feel period-appropriate, and it raises the stakes for a heroine who has little power but plenty of nerve. The best books let her push back and change him rather than just yield to him.

Books to try

These are titles readers commonly associate with the trope. Check each one against your own comfort level.

  • Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë (1847). The model for the plain, plainspoken heroine and a brooding, controlling hero. It is a Victorian novel rather than a modern romance, and it is darker than many readers expect.
  • Whitney, My Love by Judith McNaught (1985). A Regency-set classic of the 1980s boom with a forceful duke and a spirited heroine. The hero’s behavior is the kind many modern readers find hard going.
  • A Kingdom of Dreams by Judith McNaught (1989). A medieval-set romance with a fierce knight and a Scottish heroine.
  • The Bride by Julie Garwood (1989). A Highland laird and an English heroine who is gentle but stubborn, in a story with plenty of humor.
  • Marrying Winterborne by Lisa Kleypas (2016). A Victorian-set story of a powerful, driven businessman and a shy heroine.

For Plain Jane and wallflower heroines specifically, Lisa Kleypas’s Wallflowers series, which opens with Secrets of a Summer Night (2004), is a well-known place to start.

Content notes

Older books in particular may include behavior that reads as coercive or controlling. Read recent reviews for content warnings, and consider the era a book was written in as well as the era it depicts. If you prefer your alpha hero with more respect for the heroine’s choices, look for reviewers using words like “grovel” or “protective, not controlling.”

The alpha-and-innocent setup often arrives with another situation attached. Many stories use a marriage of convenience or a forced marriage to bring the pair together. Others add an age gap, or give the hero a damaged past in the style of the scarred hero.

The complete guide to historical romance

Historical Romance Novels: A Complete Reader's Guide
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →