Indian Historical Fiction

A Passage to India as a Historical Novel

E. M. Forster's A Passage to India (1924) is a colonial-era novel now read as history. Plot, why Adela accused Aziz, why Forster wrote it, and how to read it today.

On this page
  1. Overview
  2. Is it historical fiction?
  3. The historical setting
  4. Plot in brief
  5. Why did Adela accuse Aziz?
  6. Why did Forster write it?
  7. Did E. M. Forster have a lover?
  8. In which language was the earliest Indian novel written?
  9. Adaptations and reading it today

Overview

A Passage to India was published in 1924 by the English novelist E. M. Forster. It is set in the fictional city of Chandrapore, in British India, and centres on the friendship, or failed friendship, between an Indian Muslim doctor, Dr Aziz, and the English schoolmaster Cyril Fielding, and on a disastrous trip to the Marabar Caves. It is considered one of the best-known English novels about the British Raj.

Is it historical fiction?

Strictly speaking, it was written as a contemporary novel, not as a reconstruction of a distant past. (For the usual rules of thumb, see how far back a novel must be set to count as historical fiction.) A hundred years on, it reads as a portrait of colonial India in the early 1920s, with all the attitudes, assumptions and tensions of that time. That is why it is commonly included in lists of historical novels about India: it is a document of its period as much as a story. Readers should keep in mind that it is an outsider’s view. Forster was an Englishman who spent limited time in India, and Indian critics have discussed both what the book gets right and what it leaves out.

The historical setting

Forster visited India in 1912–13 and again in 1921, when he worked as private secretary to the Maharaja of Dewas State Senior. The novel reflects a period of rising nationalism and strained relations between British officials and Indians. The Marabar Caves are modelled on real caves in Bihar, the Barabar Hills. Many readers connect the book’s mood to the aftermath of the 1919 Amritsar massacre, though the novel does not make that explicit.

Plot in brief

Spoilers follow.

Adela Quested and Mrs Moore travel to India. Adela is considering marriage to Mrs Moore’s son, Ronny Heaslop, a city magistrate. Both women want to see the “real India”. Aziz organises an expedition to the Marabar Caves. Something happens to Adela in one of the caves, she leaves in distress and accuses Aziz of assaulting her. He is arrested. At the trial, with the whole British community and the Indian community watching, Adela withdraws the accusation. Fielding, who has supported Aziz, and Aziz himself drift apart afterwards. The ending suggests that friendship across the colonial divide is not yet possible.

Why did Adela accuse Aziz?

The novel deliberately does not give a clear answer. Within the story, Adela has an unsettling experience in the dark cave and is confused and frightened. Her accusation grows out of that confusion, the echoing sound that disturbs her, and the expectations of the British community around her, who are quick to believe the worst. At the trial she finds she cannot sustain the charge and retracts it. Critics have offered many interpretations, including hallucination, repressed fear and anxiety about her engagement. Forster himself left the question open, which is part of the book’s power.

Why did Forster write it?

Forster’s experiences in India and his friendships there, especially with the Indian scholar Syed Ross Masood, to whom the book is dedicated, are usually cited as the main inspiration. He wanted to explore whether personal friendship between English and Indian people could survive the pressures of empire. The novel’s answer is sceptical, though it is not without hope. It was a success when published and won the James Tait Black Memorial Prize.

Did E. M. Forster have a lover?

Forster was gay, and for most of his life he kept this private because homosexuality was illegal in Britain. Biographers describe a close relationship with Mohammed el Adl, an Egyptian tram conductor whom he met in Alexandria during the First World War, and a later long relationship with Bob Buckingham, a police officer. His novel Maurice, about a gay love story, was written in the 1910s but published only after his death, in 1971. Some biographers have suggested his feelings for Masood may have been unreturned, but this should be treated as interpretation.

In which language was the earliest Indian novel written?

There is no single agreed answer. Claims are made for several languages: Marathi (Yamunaparyatan, 1857), Bengali (Alaler Gharer Dulal, 1858) and, among others, Tamil (Prathapa Mudaliar Charithram, 1879). Bankim Chandra Chatterjee’s first novel, Rajmohan’s Wife (1864), was written in English. Which is counted as “first” depends on definitions of the word novel, so most scholars avoid a single answer. For a later landmark, see our guide to Anandamath as a historical novel.

Adaptations and reading it today

David Lean directed a film version in 1984, for which Peggy Ashcroft won an Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress. To read the book well, it helps to pair it with an Indian author’s treatment of the same era. For a broader look at the Raj and what came after, see our overview of famous historical novels of India.

The complete guide to indian historical fiction

Famous Historical Novels of India
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →