Genre Basics

How Far Back Must a Novel Be Set to Count as Historical Fiction?

There is no single rule. Organisations cite gaps of 35, 50 or 60 years, and many writers say research, not memory, is the real test. Here is how to decide.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. The age of the setting vs the age of the book
  3. Benchmarks used by different groups
  4. Why there is no single number
  5. The research-not-memory test
  6. Does it need real history in it?
  7. When an era “becomes” historical
  8. A practical rule of thumb

The short answer

There is no single official rule. A novel does not need to be old to be historical fiction; what matters is the gap between when it was written and when it is set, and, for many people, whether the author had to research the period rather than remember it. Some organisations use a cutoff of roughly 50 years, others use shorter or longer gaps, and many readers apply their own judgement.

The age of the setting vs the age of the book

These are two different things, and people often mix them up.

  • A new book can be historical fiction. A novel published this year about the nineteenth century, or about the 1960s, is historical fiction.
  • An old book is not automatically historical fiction. A novel written in the 1810s about its own time was contemporary fiction when it appeared, however old it is now. Jane Austen’s novels are an example: they were about the world her readers lived in. On the other hand, Charles Dickens’s A Tale of Two Cities is historical fiction, because it looks back at the French Revolution, which was already history when he wrote.

So the question is how far back the story is set, measured from when the book was written.

Benchmarks used by different groups

Different organisations draw the line in different places. The figures below are as reported by Book Riot and similar sources, and they may change over time, so check the current rules if you need them for a competition or a submission.

Group or prize Reported cutoff
Historical Writers’ Association About 35 years before publication
Historical Novel Society About 50 years, or written by someone who was not alive at the time of the events
Walter Scott Prize for Historical Fiction About 60 years before publication
Langum prize A fixed boundary at 1950 rather than a sliding one

Some definitions in reference works mention shorter gaps, around 25 years. There is also a prize from the Society of American Historians whose criteria, as described by Book Riot, focus on historical understanding and authenticity rather than on a number of years.

Why there is no single number

  • Different purposes. A prize needs a clear rule to decide eligibility. A bookshop needs a shelf label. A reader may just want a different-feeling world.
  • Pace of change. Fifty years ago and fifty years before that are not the same sort of distance. Technology, social attitudes and daily life changed fast in some periods and slowly in others.
  • Who is asking. A writer, a reader and a bookseller may each give a different answer.

The research-not-memory test

Many writers prefer a test based on experience instead of years. Margaret Atwood is often quoted as defining historical fiction as fiction set in a time before the writer came to consciousness. The idea is that when you write about a period you did not live through, you have to learn it and imagine it, and that process shapes the book.

Under this test, a twenty-year-old writing about 1976 is writing historical fiction, while a seventy-year-old writing about the same year may be drawing on memory. The test is appealing, but it is not widely used by organisations because it depends on the author, not the book. The Historical Novel Society’s wording, as quoted by the novelist Emma Darwin, is an either/or of the two ideas.

Does it need real history in it?

Another question is whether a story has to involve recognisable historical events or people. A Regency romance, for instance, may be rich in period detail but have no real events at all. Some critics suggest calling books like this “period pieces” and reserving “historical fiction” for stories that engage with real events or figures; others do not make this distinction. Both views are common, so it is fine to use either label when you talk about such books.

When an era “becomes” historical

Readers and booksellers often feel an era turn historical when it starts to feel like another country. For example, the Second World War has been described by some in publishing as having only recently become historical fiction, since fewer people now remember it first-hand. By that logic, the 1980s and 1990s are moving into view as settings, because many readers now associate them with the absence of smartphones and social media.

A practical rule of thumb

If you need a quick answer:

  1. Is the story set at least about 50 years before it was written? If yes, most people would call it historical fiction.
  2. If the gap is 30 to 50 years, it is a borderline case. Ask whether the author researched the period and whether it reads as a distinct, vanished world.
  3. If the gap is under 30 years, it is usually treated as contemporary or recent-past fiction, though there are exceptions where the focus is a specific historical event.

For a fuller picture of the genre, start with what is historical fiction. To place a setting in time, see our historical periods timeline, and to see how novels relate to the historical record, read history vs historical fiction.

The complete guide to genre basics

What Is Historical Fiction? Definition and Key Elements
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →