Genre Basics

Alternate History vs Historical Fiction: How the Two Genres Differ

Historical fiction keeps real events intact; alternate history changes one and explores the consequences. See the differences, examples and grey areas between them.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Historical fiction in brief
  3. Alternate history in brief
  4. Side by side
  5. Examples
  6. The grey areas
  7. Why readers choose one or the other
  8. If you are writing

The short answer

Historical fiction places invented stories inside the real past, while leaving the known course of history intact. Alternate history changes something that really happened, such as the result of a war or the survival of a leader, and asks what the world would look like afterwards. The first asks “what was it like?” The second asks “what if it had gone differently?”

Historical fiction in brief

In historical fiction, the setting and the major events follow the historical record. Authors invent characters, conversations and personal stories, but they generally do not change well-established outcomes. A novel about a fictional family in the London Blitz, for instance, would keep the real bombing and the eventual result of the war. For the full definition, see what is historical fiction.

Alternate history in brief

Alternate history, sometimes called alternative history or allohistory, starts from a point of divergence: a moment where events go a different way from the way they went in reality. The story then follows the consequences, which can be small or sweeping. Typically:

  • The change is deliberate and central. The “what if” is the premise of the book.
  • The new timeline stays changed. It does not rejoin real history.
  • The world is recognisable but different. The author often works out how institutions, technology, borders and daily life would plausibly have developed.
  • It is usually shelved as speculative fiction. Many bookshops place it near science fiction, though it is not necessarily futuristic.

Side by side

Historical fiction Alternate history
Treatment of history Keeps known events and outcomes Changes a real event on purpose
Central question What was life like then? What if it had gone another way?
Timeline The real one A new one that diverges from the real one
Research Deep research into the period Deep research into the period, plus a plausible chain of consequences
Usual shelf Fiction / historical fiction Science fiction / speculative fiction / alternate history
Typical risk Anachronism and inaccuracy An implausible chain of consequences

Examples

  • Historical fiction: The Pillars of the Earth by Ken Follett (twelfth-century England); All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr (Second World War); Wolf Hall by Hilary Mantel (Tudor court).
  • Alternate history: The Man in the High Castle by Philip K. Dick (a world in which the Axis powers won the Second World War); The Years of Rice and Salt by Kim Stanley Robinson (a world in which the Black Death kills far more of Europe’s population than it did in reality).

The grey areas

Some books sit on the border.

  • Secret history. The real events happen as recorded, but the story adds a hidden layer behind the scenes. If the outcome does not change, many readers consider this closer to historical fiction, sometimes with a fantasy or thriller twist.
  • Fantasy in a real era. Dragons in the Napoleonic Wars, as in Naomi Novik’s His Majesty’s Dragon, is both historical fantasy and alternate history, because the dragons change how events unfold. See historical fiction vs historical fantasy.
  • Time travel. A traveller who tries to change the past can lead to an alternate timeline, or to a closed loop in which history is unchanged. These books may be classed as science fiction.
  • Small changes. A novel that adjusts a minor detail, such as the date of a meeting, is still treated as historical fiction by most readers. Alternate history usually requires a change significant enough to alter the course of events.

Why readers choose one or the other

Readers of historical fiction often want immersion in a real past and the sense of learning something along the way. Readers of alternate history often enjoy the intellectual game of tracing consequences and recognising how contingent events were. Contingency is one of the ideas in the 5 C’s of historical thinking, and alternate history makes it the main attraction.

If you are writing

Choose historical fiction if you want to show a real period faithfully and put invented people in it. Choose alternate history if your central idea is a single change and its ripple effects. Either way, readers will expect you to understand the real period first, since a believable “what if” depends on knowing what actually happened.

For a wider map, see our guide to the subgenres of historical fiction.

The complete guide to genre basics

What Is Historical Fiction? Definition and Key Elements
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →