Genre Basics

Is there a difference between historical fiction and historical fantasy?

Yes. Historical fiction keeps to realistic events in a real past; historical fantasy adds magic or the supernatural. See the key differences and grey areas.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What historical fiction does
  3. What historical fantasy does
  4. Side by side
  5. Grey areas
  6. How to decide where a book fits

The short answer

Yes. Historical fiction tells a realistic, invented story in a real past, and it follows the world as it actually worked. Historical fantasy also uses a real or historically inspired past, but it adds magic, mythical creatures or other supernatural elements that are real within the story. Many people see historical fantasy as a cousin or subgenre of historical fiction that crosses into fantasy.

What historical fiction does

In historical fiction, the rules of the world are the ones that applied in that period: no real magic, no dragons, and no changes to the major historical outcomes. Characters may believe in witchcraft, omens or miracles, as many people in past eras did, but the story does not confirm that these things really work.

For a fuller definition, see what is historical fiction.

What historical fantasy does

Historical fantasy keeps a recognisable past setting but breaks the realistic rules. The magic can be open, with wizards and dragons visible to everyone, or hidden, with a secret world operating beside real events.

A commonly cited example is Susanna Clarke’s Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell, in which magic returns to England during the Napoleonic Wars, and magicians take part in real historical events. Another is Naomi Novik’s His Majesty’s Dragon, which places dragons in the Napoleonic era. The second book also changes aspects of the era, which pushes it towards alternate history as well.

Side by side

Historical fiction Historical fantasy
Setting Real past Real or historically inspired past
Magic or supernatural Absent, or only believed in by characters Real within the story
Treatment of major events Normally left unchanged May be left alone or reshaped by magic
Reader expectation Realism and period authenticity Wonder and a believable magic system
Where it is often shelved Fiction or historical fiction Fantasy

Grey areas

The line is not always sharp, and readers and critics disagree about some books.

  • Belief without proof. If characters think a curse is real, but nothing in the story confirms it, many readers would still call the book historical fiction. If the curse demonstrably works, it is fantasy.
  • Invented kingdoms with no magic. A story set in a fictional country modelled on medieval Europe, with no magic, can be hard to classify. It is not tied to a real past, so many call it fantasy or “secondary-world” fiction even without magic.
  • Mythology treated as history. Retellings of myths, such as the Trojan War, may include gods. Whether they count as historical fiction or fantasy depends on how the gods are presented.
  • Time slip and ghost stories. A modern character who visits the past, or a ghost who appears in a historical story, adds a supernatural element.
  • Alternate history. Changing the outcome of a real event is a separate move from adding magic, although the two are often combined. See alternate history vs historical fiction.

How to decide where a book fits

Ask three questions:

  1. Is the supernatural real in this story? If yes, it is fantasy or has a fantasy element.
  2. Are real historical outcomes changed? If yes, it leans towards alternate history.
  3. Would the book still make sense if you removed the magic? If so, the magic may be a light touch in an otherwise historical story.

Publishers and booksellers often shelve books by marketing as much as by definition, so the same book may appear in different sections in different shops. For a map of the neighbouring categories, see our guide to the subgenres of historical fiction.

The complete guide to genre basics

What Is Historical Fiction? Definition and Key Elements
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →