The 5 C’s at a glance
The 5 C’s of historical thinking are:
- Change over time
- Context
- Causality
- Contingency
- Complexity
They are a framework for thinking about the past beyond memorising names and dates. The framework is generally credited to the historians Thomas Andrews and Flannery Burke, who set it out in an article for the American Historical Association in 2007. Some historians have since suggested adding other concepts; for example, an AHA piece in 2024 argued for “continuity” as a sixth C.
Each C explained
1. Change over time
History looks at how things develop, shift or stay the same across months, years or centuries. Asking “what changed, and what did not?” helps you avoid treating a period as frozen. Historians also divide the past into periods to make change easier to describe, though the boundaries are somewhat arbitrary (see our historical periods timeline).
In fiction: a family saga covering several generations can show change over time directly, such as how daily life, work and beliefs shift between grandparent and grandchild.
2. Context
Events and sources only make sense within their surroundings: the social, political, economic and cultural world in which they happened. A letter, a law or a decision can mean something very different depending on who wrote it, to whom, and when.
In fiction: context is why a character’s choices should fit their time. A woman in the sixteenth century had different legal rights and options than one in the twentieth, and a good novel reflects that.
3. Causality
Causality asks why things happened. Historians look for multiple, interacting causes rather than a single trigger, and they distinguish long-term causes from immediate ones.
In fiction: a novel can dramatise causes by showing how pressures such as famine, debt, ambition or religious conflict push individual characters towards the events of the period.
4. Contingency
Contingency is the idea that outcomes depend on specific conditions, choices and chance, rather than following a single inevitable path. Things could have gone differently. This does not mean anything was possible, only that outcomes were not fixed in advance.
In fiction: contingency is the raw material of alternate history, which asks “what if?” about a pivotal moment. It also helps ordinary historical fiction avoid giving characters knowledge of the future. See alternate history vs historical fiction.
5. Complexity
Complexity means accepting that the past involved many perspectives, contradictions and competing motives, and that neat answers are often misleading. People in the same event could experience it very differently.
In fiction: complexity is a strength of the novel form, because it can show a single event through several characters’ eyes without needing to resolve them into one verdict.
Using the 5 C’s to read a historical novel
When you read a historical novel, you can ask:
- Change: what has changed in this world, and what is staying the same?
- Context: which aspects of the period shape what the characters can do?
- Causality: what forces drive the plot, and are they realistic for the time?
- Contingency: does the story treat the outcome as inevitable, or does it show chance and choice?
- Complexity: whose viewpoints are included, and whose are missing?
This is a good basis for an essay or a book-club discussion, and it helps you separate what a novel can show you from what only history can prove. For that distinction, see history vs historical fiction.
Using them to write one
Writers can use the same list as a checklist. Check that your characters act in line with their context, that events have layered causes, and that the people in your story do not behave as if they know how things will turn out. An overview of the genre’s conventions is in what is historical fiction, and a short primer on the discipline itself is in what history is in three sentences.