War Novels

Is scorched-earth policy legal?

Is scorched-earth policy legal? International humanitarian law restricts it, especially when it targets civilians. Here is a cautious overview, with history and fiction.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. What scorched earth means
  3. What international law says
  4. The exception for national territory
  5. Who is bound
  6. How the rules developed
  7. Scorched earth in historical fiction

Short answer

It depends on what is destroyed, where and why. Under modern international humanitarian law, a scorched-earth policy aimed at civilians is prohibited. Destroying food, crops, livestock, drinking water and other things civilians need to survive, in order to starve or drive out civilians, is banned. Some narrower forms of destruction can still be lawful when they are limited to legitimate military objectives and required by military necessity. This is a general overview, not legal advice, and any specific case turns on its facts.

What scorched earth means

“Scorched earth” describes a strategy of destroying everything an enemy could use, such as crops, supplies, buildings, bridges and railways. A retreating army may use it to leave nothing for pursuers, or an advancing army may use it to cut off guerrillas from the people who feed and hide them. The term entered English in the 1930s in reports on the Sino-Japanese War, though the practice is far older.

What international law says

Several rules apply:

  • Additional Protocol I (1977) to the Geneva Conventions, Article 54. It prohibits attacking, destroying, removing or rendering useless objects indispensable to the survival of the civilian population, such as foodstuffs, crops, livestock and drinking water supplies, when done to deny them to civilians or to an adversary for their sustenance value. It also bans starvation of civilians as a method of warfare.
  • Hague Regulations (1907), Article 23(g). It forbids destroying or seizing enemy property unless demanded by the necessities of war.
  • Fourth Geneva Convention (1949), Article 53. It prohibits destruction of property in occupied territory unless absolutely necessary for military operations.
  • Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. It lists intentionally using starvation of civilians as a method of warfare, and destruction of property not justified by military necessity, among war crimes in international armed conflicts.

The exception for national territory

Article 54 of Additional Protocol I includes a limited exception. In defence of its own national territory against invasion, a party to the conflict may, where required by imperative military necessity, depart from the ban in areas under its own control. This does not permit attacks on civilians, and it is read narrowly. It has no equivalent for destruction in occupied or enemy territory.

Who is bound

Treaties bind the states that have ratified them. Most states are party to the Geneva Conventions, but not every state has ratified Additional Protocol I; the United States, for example, signed it but has not ratified it. Many of the underlying principles, including the protection of civilians and the limits of military necessity, are also considered binding as customary international law. Rules for non-international conflicts and for specific weapons are separate subjects.

How the rules developed

The modern rules came after centuries in which scorched earth was a standard tool:

  • 1812: Russia’s retreat before Napoleon’s army, including the loss of supplies along the route, is a well-known example.
  • American Civil War: The Union’s 1863 Lieber Code, an early effort to codify the laws of war, accepted destruction and even hunger as legitimate means of pressuring an enemy where justified by military necessity. General William T. Sherman’s 1864 campaign through Georgia and Philip Sheridan’s operations in the Shenandoah Valley are the best-known cases.
  • Second Boer War (1899–1902): British forces destroyed farms and held civilians in camps, where many died of disease. The camps drew criticism, notably from Emily Hobhouse.
  • World War II: German forces carried out scorched-earth withdrawals in the Soviet Union, Norway and Finland. In March 1945, Hitler issued the “Nero Decree” ordering widespread destruction within Germany; armaments minister Albert Speer worked to avoid carrying it out.

After the war, the Geneva Conventions and the 1977 protocols narrowed what states may do. Allegations of scorched-earth tactics in later conflicts are frequently discussed by UN bodies and rights groups, and assessments of individual cases are matters for courts and investigators.

Scorched earth in historical fiction

Novels often use scorched earth to show what war does to ordinary people. Civil War fiction in particular returns to burned farms, displaced families and ruined landscapes; our best American Civil War historical fiction guide lists several, and This Scorched Earth is a recent example centered on one family. For the wider category, see the best historical war novels.

The complete guide to war novels

Best Historical War Novels: WWII and Beyond
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →