War Novels

This Scorched Earth: A Novel of the Civil War

An overview of This Scorched Earth, W. Michael Gear's 2019 novel of a family broken by the Civil War and rebuilding in the American West: premise, themes and who it suits.

On this page
  1. What This Scorched Earth is
  2. Premise and characters
  3. Themes: trauma, healing and the frontier
  4. The author
  5. Why “scorched earth”?
  6. Who will like it
  7. Related reading

What This Scorched Earth is

This Scorched Earth: A Novel of the Civil War and the American West is a historical novel by W. Michael Gear, published by Forge Books in 2019. Some booksellers list the author as William Gear. The book follows a family from the wreckage of the Civil War in Arkansas to a new start in the American West.

Where many Civil War novels focus on a single famous battle, This Scorched Earth is a family saga. Its subject is the aftermath: what happens to ordinary people after the fighting, and how they put their lives together again.

Premise and characters

According to the publisher’s description, the Hancock family of rural Arkansas lost everything in the war and went through what is described as “an unimaginable hell.” The central characters are the Hancock siblings: Doc, Sarah, Butler and Billy. Each is traumatized, and the story asks how a person recovers and whether they choose “damnation or redemption.”

The American frontier plays a double role. It is a real place, with its own dangers and opportunities, and it is also, in the publisher’s words, a metaphor for the wilderness within. I will not describe the plot beyond that summary, so you can read without spoilers.

Themes: trauma, healing and the frontier

The book’s main themes, as presented by the publisher, are:

  • Trauma and recovery. The war is treated as a psychological injury as much as a political event.
  • Family bonds. The story is built around four siblings rather than a single hero.
  • Redemption and its cost. Self-salvation, the description says, “always comes with a price.”
  • The movement west. Many Americans moved west after the war, and the book places its family in that larger migration.

The author

W. Michael Gear is a bestselling author who holds a master’s degree in archaeology. He is widely known for the North America’s Forgotten Past series of prehistoric novels, co-written with Kathleen O’Neal Gear. The publisher presents This Scorched Earth as a major personal project that draws on his research and archaeological training.

Why “scorched earth”?

“Scorched earth” is a military strategy of destroying anything an enemy could use, including crops, buildings and supplies. In the Civil War, the term is closely associated with Union campaigns in Georgia and the Shenandoah Valley. In this novel’s title, it also reads as a description of what the war left behind for families like the Hancocks. If you are curious about the real strategy, our explainer on whether scorched-earth policy is legal covers the history and the law.

Who will like it

This is likely to appeal to readers who enjoy:

  • Multi-generation or family sagas.
  • Westerns and frontier fiction with historical grounding. If you also enjoy romance, see our Western historical romance list.
  • Character-driven stories about trauma and recovery.

It may suit you less if you want a battlefield-by-battlefield war narrative. Because the book deals with a violent period and traumatized characters, expect difficult content. Check current reader reviews for specifics.

For more Civil War fiction, see our best American Civil War historical fiction, which goes beyond this title. For historical background, read What was the real reason the Civil War started? For other war fiction, return to the best historical war novels.

The complete guide to war novels

Best Historical War Novels: WWII and Beyond
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →