War Novels

Is the razor's edge worth reading?

Is W. Somerset Maugham's The Razor's Edge worth reading? A spoiler-light look at its post-WWI story, themes, drawbacks and who is likely to enjoy it.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. What the novel is about
  3. Why it belongs in a war-fiction reading list
  4. What works
  5. What may put readers off
  6. Who should read it, who might skip
  7. Film adaptations

Short answer

For many readers, yes, particularly if you like character-driven novels about meaning and purpose and are curious about life after the First World War. The Razor’s Edge (1944) by W. Somerset Maugham is not a conventional war novel and has little combat in it. It may be less satisfying if you want a fast plot or a modern sensibility. Opinion among readers is divided, so a sample of the first chapters is a reasonable test.

What the novel is about

The story is narrated by a character named Maugham, a writer who observes a circle of acquaintances across Chicago, Paris, London and the French Riviera between the end of the First World War and the 1930s. At its centre is Larry Darrell, a young American who served in the war as an airman and returns unable to settle into the ordinary ambitions of his friends and fiancée, Isabel. He leaves to look for something he cannot quite name, and the book follows his search, including a journey to India, alongside the lives of people who choose security and status instead.

The title comes from a line in the Katha Upanishad, often rendered as the path to salvation being as hard to cross as the sharp edge of a razor.

Why it belongs in a war-fiction reading list

Larry’s restlessness begins with the war. A traumatic experience in combat, which the novel treats with restraint, leaves him unable to accept an easy life. In that sense it is an aftermath novel, in the same family as books like The Return of the Soldier and other novels discussed in our World War I novels list. It also illustrates the point made in How did the Great War influence literature?: the war reshaped not just battle writing but novels about ordinary lives afterwards.

What works

  • A distinctive narrator. Maugham writes himself in as an observer, which gives the book a conversational, worldly tone.
  • Memorable supporting characters. Elliott Templeton, a status-obsessed American in Paris, is often singled out.
  • A serious question. The book takes seriously the question of how to live after a shock, and does not give a tidy answer.

What may put readers off

  • Pacing. Much of the book is conversation and reflection, and some readers find the middle slow.
  • Dated attitudes. Its portrayal of social class, gender and of India and Eastern spirituality reflects the 1940s and can feel simplified or patronizing to modern readers.
  • Ambiguity. Larry’s spiritual journey is described largely from the outside, which some readers find unsatisfying.

Who should read it, who might skip

Read it if you enjoy Maugham’s other work, mid-century novels of ideas, or stories about people who step away from convention.

Skip it if you want a plot-heavy war story, a deeply researched historical reconstruction or a book that engages with its themes from a contemporary viewpoint. If you prefer those, see the best historical war novels.

Film adaptations

The novel has been filmed twice: a 1946 version with Tyrone Power and a 1984 version with Bill Murray. They differ in tone and detail from the book, so seeing one is not a substitute for reading it.

The complete guide to war novels

Best Historical War Novels: WWII and Beyond
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →