What is a historical novel, in simple words?
A historical novel is a work of fiction set in a real period of the past. Its story is invented, but it takes place in a world shaped by actual events, places and often real people. The author researches the era and tries to make it feel believable, while still telling a story.
Ivanhoe (published at the end of 1819, with 1820 on the title page) is one of the best-known examples. It was written by Sir Walter Scott, whom many call the father of the historical novel. For more about him, see Sir Walter Scott as a historical novelist.
The setting and plot in brief
The novel is set in England in the late twelfth century, after Richard I (the Lionheart) has been captured on his way back from the Third Crusade. His brother, Prince John, is trying to take power. Society is divided, as Scott tells it, between the Norman nobility who rule and the Saxons who have been pushed down.
The title character, Wilfred of Ivanhoe, is a Saxon knight who is disinherited by his father, Cedric, for supporting Richard. He returns from the Crusade in disguise. Around him are a large cast:
- Rowena, Cedric’s ward and the woman Ivanhoe loves.
- Rebecca, the daughter of the Jewish moneylender Isaac of York, who nurses Ivanhoe.
- Brian de Bois-Guilbert, a Templar knight who becomes obsessed with Rebecca.
- Locksley, the archer who later turns out to be Robin Hood, along with Friar Tuck.
- Wamba and Gurth, Cedric’s jester and swineherd.
- Richard himself, who appears in disguise as the Black Knight.
The plot includes a tournament at Ashby, an imprisonment and siege at Torquilstone castle, and a trial by combat.
How Ivanhoe works as a historical novel
- Real period, invented plot. Richard I, Prince John and the Templars are real. Ivanhoe, Rowena and Rebecca are Scott’s creations.
- A society in conflict. Scott builds the story around a clash between two peoples, Saxons and Normans, which gives the plot a larger historical stake.
- Texture of the era. Tournaments, castles, outlaws in the forest, feudal obligations and religious orders supply the setting. Scott drew on antiquarian sources for much of this.
- Language. He gives characters archaic-sounding speech and sprinkles in period vocabulary. This signals “the past” to readers, although it is not an accurate record of how people spoke.
- Romance over realism. The mix of adventure, chivalry and a love plot places the book closer to the older tradition of romance than to strict realism, which is why it is often called a historical romance.
Where Scott departs from history
Scott was not trying to write a documentary, and historians have long pointed out his liberties:
- Saxon versus Norman. By the 1190s, more than a century after the Norman Conquest, the two groups had largely intermingled, especially among the upper classes. The sharp, ongoing hostility in the novel is likely exaggerated. Historians commonly describe it as reflecting nineteenth-century concerns more than twelfth-century ones.
- Robin Hood. Robin Hood legends have uncertain origins, and the version in which Robin leads Saxon outlaws against Norman lords in Richard’s time owes a lot to Scott.
- Details of daily life. Armor, tournament customs and some institutions are drawn from later centuries.
- Language. Real people at the time would not have spoken in Scott’s “thee” and “thou” style.
None of this reduces the book’s value as fiction, but it is a reminder to treat Ivanhoe as a picture of how the nineteenth century imagined the Middle Ages.
Themes
- Identity and division. The Saxon-Norman split drives the plot and tests loyalty.
- Chivalry. Scott celebrates the ideals of knighthood while showing how often knights fall short of them.
- Prejudice. Isaac and Rebecca face persecution. Rebecca is often considered the book’s most memorable character, and her treatment makes readers confront the cruelty directed at Jewish characters. Modern readers may find some portrayals dated even where Scott meant them sympathetically.
- Legitimate rule. Richard’s return restores order, but the story leaves room for questions about who deserves power.
Legacy
Ivanhoe helped fuel the nineteenth-century enthusiasm for the Middle Ages, in art, architecture and pageantry. It shaped the popular image of Robin Hood and of knights in armor. It has been adapted many times for stage, film and television.
Who does Ivanhoe marry?
Ivanhoe marries Rowena. Rebecca, who is in love with him, does not marry him; she and her father leave England for Granada at the end. Many readers feel that Rebecca is the more compelling character, and that the ending favors the conventional match.
How hard is it to read?
Students ask about difficulty, and the honest answer is that it depends on the reader. The novel is long, the vocabulary is demanding and the early chapters set a slow pace. Abridged and annotated editions exist. We discuss page count in how many pages is Ivanhoe. Many schools treat it as upper-secondary reading, but there is no single official grade level.
Austen and Scott
Jane Austen wrote a joking letter in 1814 complaining that Scott, already successful as a poet, should not be writing novels as well, since he was taking readers from other novelists. The remark referred to Waverley, not Ivanhoe, which came later. It shows how well-known Scott was within a short time of switching to fiction.