Why Scott is called the father of the historical novel
Sir Walter Scott (1771–1832) was a Scottish poet, lawyer and collector of ballads who turned to fiction in his early forties. His first novel, Waverley (1814), was published anonymously and was an immediate success. Over the next dozen or so years he produced a series now known as the Waverley novels, set in periods from the Middle Ages to the eighteenth century.
He is not the only writer who set fiction in the past, but he gave the form its recognizable shape and brought it a very large readership. For a wider look at the writers who followed him, see our guide to the great historical novelists in English.
Scott’s novels at a glance
This is a selection, not a complete list:
- Waverley (1814): the 1745 Jacobite rising, seen through a young English officer.
- Guy Mannering (1815) and The Antiquary (1816): later-eighteenth-century Scotland.
- Old Mortality (1816): the Covenanters in seventeenth-century Scotland.
- Rob Roy (1817): the Highlands and the early eighteenth century.
- The Heart of Midlothian (1818): Edinburgh and the Porteous riots of 1736.
- The Bride of Lammermoor (1819): a tragic romance, later the source of Donizetti’s opera.
- Ivanhoe (1819): twelfth-century England. See our analysis of Ivanhoe as a historical novel.
- Kenilworth (1821): Elizabethan England.
- Quentin Durward (1823): fifteenth-century France.
Scott’s most famous novel depends on who is answering. Ivanhoe is probably the best known to general readers, while many critics value the Scottish novels more highly.
How Scott’s method worked
A few habits recur across the novels:
- A fairly ordinary protagonist. The hero is often a thoughtful, somewhat passive young man who is pulled between two sides of a conflict, such as Jacobites and Hanoverians. This lets Scott show both sides.
- Real figures at the edges. Kings, generals and rebels appear, but the plot centers on invented characters.
- Customs and speech. Scott lingers on dialect, dress, food, landscape and local legend, much of it drawn from his antiquarian interests.
- A period of transition. His strongest books look at moments when an older way of life is giving way to a new one, such as clan society to modern Britain.
- Narrative distance. Waverley carries the subtitle ’Tis Sixty Years Since, signaling that the events are far enough back to be history but near enough to have living witnesses.
The Hungarian critic Georg Lukács, in The Historical Novel (1937), argued that this focus on social change made Scott the founder of the form. Not everyone agrees with his reading, but it remains an influential one.
The historical novel in the Romantic period
Scott wrote at the height of British Romanticism, roughly the 1790s to the 1830s. Several features of the period shaped his fiction:
- Interest in the national past. Collecting ballads, ruins and folklore was fashionable, and Scott himself published ballad collections and long narrative poems such as The Lady of the Lake.
- Reaction to rapid change. Industrialization and the Napoleonic wars made readers curious about how their societies had come to be.
- Taste for romance. In older usage, a “romance” was a tale of adventure, love and the marvelous, as distinct from the realistic “novel.” Scott’s work sits between the two, which is why Ivanhoe is sometimes called a historical romance.
- Regional and national identity. His portrait of Scotland strengthened a sense of Scottish heritage, though critics note that it also romanticized the Highlands.
“Historical romance” today often means a love story set in the past. That is related to, but not identical with, the older meaning. Readers looking for that modern sense might enjoy our list of Philippa Gregory’s Tudor and Plantagenet novels in order.
Scott’s influence reached beyond Britain. James Fenimore Cooper’s The Last of the Mohicans (1826) is often cited as an American example of Scott’s approach, and Hawthorne’s work shows Romantic interests in the American past. Alessandro Manzoni’s The Betrothed in Italy and Victor Hugo in France also followed in his wake.
The Heart of Midlothian as a historical novel
The Heart of Midlothian (1818) is frequently put forward as Scott’s best novel, and it is a good test case of his method.
The history. The book begins with the Porteous riots in Edinburgh in 1736. Captain John Porteous, who commanded the city guard, was convicted after soldiers fired on a crowd at a hanging. When he received a royal reprieve, a mob broke into the Tolbooth prison and lynched him. Scott builds his story around the aftermath of these real events.
The fiction. The central plot is invented. Effie Deans is convicted of concealing her pregnancy after her child disappears. Her half-sister Jeanie, a devout and plain-spoken woman, refuses to lie in court to save her, then walks to London to seek a royal pardon.
Why it works as historical fiction.
- The hero is not a nobleman or soldier but a farmer’s daughter, which expands the genre’s range.
- Real institutions (the Tolbooth, the courts, the Crown) shape the plot, and the characters are caught up in them.
- Scott writes much of the dialogue in Scots, giving the novel a strong sense of place.
- Real and imagined figures meet. The Duke of Argyll and Queen Caroline appear in the London scenes.
The Edinburgh landmark that gives the novel its name has a tradition of its own. See why people spit on the Heart of Midlothian.
Criticisms and limits
- Scott’s view of progress can feel tidy, with Highland and medieval worlds treated as picturesque rather than fully understood.
- Some plots rely on coincidence, and endings can feel hurried.
- Period details are not always accurate. In Ivanhoe, for example, the conflict between Saxons and Normans is more clear-cut than it likely was in the 1190s.
- The prose, with its long descriptions, may feel slow to modern readers.
What Jane Austen thought
Austen and Scott were contemporaries. In a letter from 1814, she joked that Scott “has no business to write novels, especially good ones,” because he already had fame and income as a poet and was taking bread from other novelists. It is playful rather than hostile, and it is often quoted as evidence of how quickly the anonymous Waverley made an impression.
Famous lines
Many of Scott’s best-known lines come from his poetry rather than his novels:
- “Oh, what a tangled web we weave, when first we practise to deceive!” (from Marmion)
- “Breathes there the man, with soul so dead, who never to himself hath said, This is my own, my native land!” (from The Lay of the Last Minstrel)
Where to start
- For adventure: Ivanhoe, though note that its language is dense.
- For the Scottish novels: Waverley or Rob Roy.
- For a more moving story: The Heart of Midlothian, if you can accept some passages in Scots.
- For Elizabethan intrigue: Kenilworth.