Short answer
People spit on the Heart of Midlothian, a heart-shaped mosaic set into the pavement beside St Giles’ Cathedral on Edinburgh’s Royal Mile, as a local tradition. The usual explanation is that it began as a gesture of contempt toward the Old Tolbooth, the grim prison and civic building that once stood on the spot. Today many people say they do it for luck. The exact origins are not well documented, and different explanations are given.
What is the Heart of Midlothian?
The Heart of Midlothian is a mosaic in the paving on the Royal Mile, near the entrance to St Giles’. It marks the location of the Old Tolbooth, which was demolished in 1817. “Midlothian” is the historic county around Edinburgh, so the name refers to the “heart” of that area.
The Old Tolbooth
The Tolbooth stood on the High Street for centuries. It served at various times as a meeting place for the town council and courts and, later, as a prison. It was associated with executions and punishment. It had a fearsome reputation among Edinburgh’s residents, which is why the site carries negative associations in local memory.
Scott’s novel
The building became more famous after Sir Walter Scott used it in his novel The Heart of Midlothian (1818), whose title is a nickname for the Tolbooth. The story is set around the real Porteous riots of 1736, when a crowd stormed the Tolbooth and seized Captain Porteous. Scott kept a connection to the building: after the demolition, he acquired part of it, and its door was incorporated into his home at Abbotsford. For more on the novel and how it uses history, see our discussion of Scott in Sir Walter Scott as a historical novelist.
Why do people spit?
Several explanations are offered, and it is hard to verify which came first:
- Contempt for the prison. The most common account says passers-by spat at the Tolbooth’s door as a sign of disdain for the institution, and the habit carried on at the mosaic.
- Luck. Over time, spitting on the heart has also come to be treated as a good-luck ritual, particularly for visitors.
- Local tradition and tourism. Guides routinely mention it, which keeps the custom alive.
Some commentators have also suggested the custom is as much a result of tour-guide storytelling as of old practice. Treat any single, confident origin story with caution.
Hearts football club
Heart of Midlothian Football Club, usually called Hearts, takes its name from the same source. Fans are sometimes said to spit on the heart as a mark of loyalty or for luck on match days. The club’s name is generally thought to come from a dance hall of that name, which in turn took its name from Scott’s novel.
Visiting
If you go, note that the practice is not universally welcomed. Some residents and visitors find it unpleasant, and the mosaic is in a busy public space. You can appreciate the history without joining in. The cathedral, the Royal Mile and nearby sites offer more on Edinburgh’s history.